Tuesday, January 7, 2014

Is Communism Dead?

First to define what Marx meant by communist society. A classless society, where the state had withered away. By that definition, communist society has never existed.  Logically, for anything or anyone to die, it or one must first exist.

The next question is defining what Marx meant by a workers democracy, as opposed to a capitalist democracy.  But first we must define the word democracy.  Or ask democracy for what economic class, workers or capitalists, or wage slaves or capitalists, or chattel slaves or their slave owners? Because, indeed the word democracy originated with chattel slavery of 2000 years or so ago.  But democracy was meant for the slave owners, not the slaves.

The question that should be asked, is why have workers who have seized power,  not been able to hold unto their power, and have had to cede that power to capitalists again?  In particular, why were workers in the Paris commune only able to hold unto power a few months, and in the Bolshevik Revolution only a few years, while under Lenin's leadership, which imo, is when workers lost power ?


The US and other European powers did all they could to defeat the Bolsheviks by using military force.  I doubt very much that when that failed, covert interventions did not take the place of military force. I can only speculate, that covertly Stalin was working with capitalist to betray the Bolsheviks.  No wiki leaks yet about that era.

Also, I think it is totally absurd to expect socialism to flourish, when every time an attempt is made, the capitalists do every thing to defeat it.  In Cuba it was the Bay of Pigs, in Chile, it was the execution of Salvador Allende by the US, and in Bolivia, it was Che Guevara.  And in Nicaragua, Reagan sent his Contras to defeat communism.  Someone on Facebook just posted something to the effect, that if you have to use force to suppress and idea, something must be wrong with your idea.

What is the reason given, by apologists of the US and or capitalism, for supporting right wing dictators all over the world?  Do they not say, to prevent the spread of communism?  So how easy is it for Marxist socialism to succeed under these circumstances?

It is not just socialists and or communists that are suppressed but also other progressives and or liberal critics of capitalism, in particular union leaders that are executed under the leadership and or training by the US, in the School of the Americas, in Ft Benning Ga.


When communism becomes a world system, when class divided society has ended, if after all that, class divided society returned to capitalism, than, one could argue, communism failed, not until that time.  Until that time, the class struggle will move forward as it has throughout history.  The class struggle remains in motion, just as every thing in the universe is.



No comments:

Post a Comment