The video, is sponsored or produced by National Geographic., And is based on a book by Jared Diamond. Jared does not mention Engels book, Origin Of The Family, Private Property and Species, in the video. But Engels had made almost identical observations over 100 years ago, and more. Marx and Engels, drew the conclusion that the abundance of food, is what made class divided society possible, slavery possible. Slavery made possible the rapid advancement in science, and also class divided society, also facilitated that advancement. The video, does not draw this conclusions directly.
IMO, this video confirms the Marxist materialist conception of history. In that Gun, Germs and Steel, all three are material things. And they were and are decisive in determining the outcome of history. While others that review this book and or video, interpret the Europeans to have a Geographical advantage, I see it mainly as a MATERIAL advantage.
This video is important in that it enriches and updates the information Engels provided over 100 years ago. But, also, this video has more meaning and importance to those having read Engels book first, IMO.
I thought it was interesting that as the Europeans expanded their conquest from South of the equator towards the equator, Germs, instead of being and advantage as had been the case in the Americas, became a disadvantage, as they did not have the immunity to resist malaria. Another point the video makes, is that it takes more intelligence to survive on meager resources than on abundant.
The weakest part of the video is the final part of the video. This is where Jared is visiting a children's hospital ward, of children dying or being treated for malaria. The lady physician being interviewed by Jared, says:
"To control malaria will result in an improvement in the welfare of the people. And an improvement in the welfare of the people will mean increased productivity and will mean we will be a wealthy nation..". How she comes to the conclusion that will mean more food and leisure time for the people, I don't have a clue. As if she is implying, curing malaria will cure inequality. And the per capital income of Zambia is about $1600, compared to Singapore which is higher than even the US. Also in my websearch, it seems Zambia's bigger health problem is Aids and not malaria. But I guess Aids was not a good fit, for Jared's thesis.
The commentator ends asking the question:
"Why is our world divided between rich and poor and how perhaps can we change it? ". Jared doesn't answer that, he sidesteps it instead.
Communist do not sidestep that question. The answer is ending the economic inequality of the capitalist system, and that requires radical change aka revolution. And more than likely that will be an armed revolution, not much different than the American Revolution.
Communists encourage as broad of knowledge of science and history as one can acquire. It is towards that end I encourage everyone to watch this very educational and informative video.
Here is the link to Engels free online book, Origin of the family I mentioned above: http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1884/origin-family/
No comments:
Post a Comment